Well - hello, Dolly! It’s been a minute! Have you changed? Are you applying retinol now? Did you switch your perfume? My answer key: always, already was, and of course.
But the question you might really be asking is: Jordan, why haven’t you posted on Substack in two years?
What you may or may not know about me is that my full-time job isn’t to flit about New York City consuming culture; rather, your girl was raised on Charlotte Pickles energy, entered the working world in the millennial Girl Boss era, and spends most of her time as a full-on corporate gal. And while I do have the opportunity to flit, most of the time I’m actually just responding to Slacks. But recently I’ve had more headspace to think about the various projects in my life. And I thought, what better place to share those thoughts than here? So let’s get into it.
Like many people this year, I was captivated by Widow’s Bay. Parks and Rec alum Katie Dippold (and author of one of my favorite tweets of all time) seamlessly toggled between horror and comedy, delivering some of the year’s best jump scares and laughs. This trend of comedy writers creating horror is hardly new - auteurs like Jordan Peele and Zach Cregger, and now Obsession newcomer Curry Barker, all have sketch comedy backgrounds. The overlap is logical: both rely on a build-up and a payoff that subverts your expectations (Cregger talked about this thoughtfully here). I’ve always been drawn to artists who aren’t beholden to genre.
When people ask me what I’m into, I struggle to respond because I’m into a whole lot of things. Friends who spent time with me this summer heard me find every available soapbox to talk about my love for Off Campus, and how simple but thrilling it was to know young viewers would see male college athletes speaking thoughtfully about consent in the context of a traditional-looking teen drama (obviously written by a woman). I grew up with the toxicity of One Tree Hill...that show, while beloved, could never. I was also first in line for the recently released, long-censored director’s cut of Ken Russell’s The Devils (it absolutely delivered on every single one of my unhinged expectations).
I’ve never had clearly drawn lines in how I think about culture - it all coexists for me. My father was as interested in the Beatles’ discography as he was in bluegrass. A car ride could begin with Dire Straits’ "Money for Nothing," but finish in a family round of John Denver’s "It’s a Sin to Tell a Lie" (to be clear - we are not vocally gifted - it did not sound great). My mother is an Anglophile, and I was fed a heavy diet of period dramas. We also loved old-time movie musicals, and Singin’ in the Rain and Bye Bye Birdie are probably still two of my most-watched films. For me, it’s not really about genre or even medium. It’s about the emotion something stirs. I live in my head and on Zoom a lot of the time. But art firmly roots me in my body. It gives me access to pieces of me that I can’t otherwise call upon.
I want to sob. I want to be startled. I want snot coming out of my nose. I want my voice to be hoarse from screaming with abandon. I want to cringe. I want to be filled with delicious anxiety. I want to experience terror (knowing no real harm is to come). I want to miss my childhood. I want to long for the family I never had the opportunity to meet. I want to be compelled to create. I want my stomach to ache with laughter. I want to believe that maybe we can collectively be better. I want to know someone else felt that thing too. I want to feel deep obsession that leads to internet sessions where I’m finding behind-the-scenes production crew photo dumps that teach me the lore. I want to dance...or I want to want to dance. I want my jaw to be stiff from hours of unbidden smiling. I want an outfit to be so deeply imprinted in my brain that several years later I’ll find a similar jacket at a vintage store and secretly cosplay that moment each time I wear it.
I JUST WANT TO FEEL SOMETHING.
By way of example, in no particular order, here are some things that made me feel stuff recently:
When Phoebe Bridgers reunited boygenius at the Barclays Center, and they sang “Not Strong Enough” and there wasn’t a single phone to record it.
Julianne Moore and Paul Giamatti going toe-to-toe in The Debut (and Jesse Eisenberg dedicating the film to “those for whom New York was an aspiration”).
The first time I heard “Camera” by Charli xcx on the weekend of my 34th birthday.
When Olivia Wilde says “namaste” in The Invite.
The internet edits of the Norway coach running to his wife during the World Cup set to Jimmy Eat World’s “Hear You Me” in homage to the 2004 classic A Cinderella Story.
Nathan Lane’s Willy Loman giving me an entirely new perspective on a play I’d never much cared for.
In Project Hail Mary, when Rocky shares that he’s been with his partner for 186.3 years but “it’s not enough.”
Rereading Mr. Darcy’s “In vain have I struggled. It will not do. My feelings will not be repressed. You must allow me to tell you how ardently I admire and love you” scene in Pride and Prejudice for the fifth time.
The dinner scene in the second half of You Can See Everything.
Loveforcaptnswn’s BRILLIANT romance film compilation to Olivia Rodrigo’s “Stupid Song.”
It probably feels different to see a collection of moments vs. a menu of recommendations. When I was sending a weekly menu, I started to feel like I was doing this thing I hate that happens in the corporate world: talking about the work vs. doing the work. I could easily say the prior iteration of this Substack became unsustainable alongside a busy life. But busyness is just a deprioritization excuse, and the truth is I found that making so many recs started to feel like creating content about content - which is just a new form of content, but isn’t me bringing my own stories into the world.
To be clear, I find so much joy in talking about art, recommending art, and participating in the shared experience of consuming art. Very little makes me happier than hearing something I recommended meant something to someone else. But, to be even more honest, there’s a real safety in being an audience member: you can own your opinions and be perceived as having taste without having to confront whether you can actually make something yourself. I’ve enjoyed the comfort of speaking about my aspirations in the abstract, rather than risking what happens when people actually consume my work.
I referenced in my last “return” post that I started this newsletter as a promise to myself - a promise that making time for any form of writing would magically motivate me to finish my half-written novel. I’m thrilled to share that I’m 80,000 words in, AND ALMOST READY TO QUERY AGENTS. One day soon (I hope), you’ll read my dark academia thriller about a college transfer student, desperate to escape being ordinary, who is unexpectedly chosen by a prestigious all-women secret society. She soon discovers the group’s sinister connection to a series of campus disappearances, and she’s forced to confront what she’s willing to overlook when belonging becomes currency. The idea grew out of my attempts to process being a Utah girl who found herself president of a Los Angeles sorority. Think Donna Tartt’s The Secret History meets Ira Levin’s The Stepford Wives, with a little Jennifer’s Body thrown in for dark, bloody comic relief. I’ve mostly been quiet about the writing process, but I want to learn how to bring people in, even when I’m struggling to reconcile all these disparate versions of myself.
I love stories. I see the world in stories, and so my natural inclination is to package my own personal story. When I meet someone and they ask what I do, I struggle to respond. Because simply telling them about my job doesn’t feel like it encompasses the totality of who I am, but saying I’m a writer doesn’t feel right either. So I start live editing the “right” response - weighing up how much I speak about my day-to-day, wondering if I mention the book, or if I’m getting too far ahead of myself. Panicking because I feel like I owe a stranger a tidy logline of my existence. Many of us are programmed for a conveyor-belt destination life. You’re good at something, so you follow it, and enjoy it, and keep at it because existing costs money. But then you find yourself asking: is this what I’m meant to do? Or should I be pursuing that thing the little voice in my head is whispering about? And if I do, how will I package it neatly when I meet that overeager friend of a friend at a cocktail party I’m actively trying to leave?
I’m proud of the life that I’ve built, and lucky in ways I don’t take for granted. But I’m trying to understand why I’m comfortable with contradiction in the art I love, but so uncomfortable with it in myself. And more importantly, I’m trying to force myself out of the comfort of the very familiar role of audience member. It would be wonderful to say that I’ve figured it out, that I’ve stopped attempting to write that cocktail party logline, and that I’m perfectly comfortable letting many versions of me coexist. But that’s just not true. The truth is I desperately want to finish this book, and I want it to be successful, and I want people to think it’s good (even behind my back). And I want this deep-seated belief that I’m capable of this to be real, and not a fantasy. But I’m also invested in a career that I’ve spent years building. And I don’t really know how those things converge, or the narrative that will emerge. But maybe I'll just try being a character in my own life for a bit, rather than over-narrativizing (wish me luck - as I narrativize once again).
I don’t know exactly what that all means, but I do know that I’m ultimately trying to figure out how to make even more space for creative work and how to bring people along. For now, you’ll mostly find me doing that on Instagram - sharing snippets of the very unglamorous creative process of writing my book while working a full-time job, cultural obsessions that my friends are growing tired of hearing about, or weirdly specific movie-inspired outfits. It will also look like writing longer-form essays here, and maybe even dabbling in TikTok or the wild world of podcasts.
Some days I’m Tess McGill. Others I’m Jo March. And even still, sometimes I’m Cher Horowitz - well-intentioned, fabulous, but clueless as ever.
So what’s making you feel stuff these days? Alternatively, what’s the weirdest thing you’ve ever said to a stranger at a cocktail party? Tell me in the comments.
💖 If you liked this post, don’t forget to hit the heart below to let me know and help others find my writing.
📸 For the moments as they happen, find me on Instagram at @jordanmbowry.
📮 And if you’re not yet subscribed, make sure to hit the subscribe button.




You are brilliant and this is brilliant. I can’t wait for more (and we have so much to discuss!).